Expired vs. old domain

Hello everyone, so I have two domain names presented to me for an old niche that I wish to dedicate myself to again.

Option one:
The domain that re-registered in 2018 still has a return link profile established in accordance with Moz (all related to the type of content I will provide)
Cheaper than option 2

Option two:
Domain aged since 2004, without link profile.

Curious what everyone thinks